Search results

  1. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    The day phase isn't over, creepa is just showing the state of the day. Swimmy was not only more active, but also more trusted than rman across the board. I do think the rman kill would've been strange coming from mafia unless he was personally threatening one or more of them somehow (possibly...
  2. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    We really shouldn't publicly speculate about who has an important role and who doesn't. It gives information to untrustworthy players that we don't want them to have. Anyway, here are a couple of my reads so far. I'll continue this later when I have more time. Z3- Leaning innocent, as...
  3. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    @Edan- I don't think you ever responded to this: As for the way Z3 is trying to lynch Luma, I think that's actually a good sign from him. We both play on a site where the gameplay is pretty hardcore and people learn to form strong opinions in the early stages in the game. I've been a bit less...
  4. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    Private Topic You can't play scum if you don't check your inbox bro
  5. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    ....oh, that's why you haven't talked in the PT
  6. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    Hey yeroc, who are your partners?
  7. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    @Luma: Fair enough. I had some sideways looks at your post on me, but it can probably be chalked up to misreading. I'm not a huge fan of how fast these votes are piling on to nahfackler. At this rate, he's very likely going to be lynched by default even if he does come back and post content...
  8. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    What do you mean? This is your second post in the game and there's no outside communication
  9. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    What about the other points that both of us have brought up about you/my question about my Edan interactions?
  10. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    So much this. And I think what a lot of people don't realize in mafia is that being really cautious and having an innocent-until-proven-guilty mindset isn't going to help catch scum the vast majority of the time. There's a fine line between reason and inaction. Creepa did say that there were...
  11. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    1) Why is aggressiveness suspicious? It's starting to get us somewhere, isn't it? 2) Uh no, I gave her innocent points for that and (I think) explained pretty clearly why I did it. 3) Reason for each of us? @bstrey It's not a very strong or reliable indicator, but it was enough to make note...
  12. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    Any opinion on my interactions with Edan/bstrey?
  13. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    Why bring it up as suspicious if you don't have a real opinion on it? I'm mostly curious because it was just such a strange thing to call someone out for either way, and without any reason or context for why it caught your eye. Questioning people is a green light in most cases if anything. As...
  14. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    I don't know what you're trying to convey here
  15. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    What forgot referred to in the commandments is a very different kind of meta if I'm not mistaken, more along the lines of grudge-killing people over past events rather than using information from previous rounds or out-of-game context to change your view of a player. It's probably fine, but it...
  16. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    I'd love to hear why this is suspicious, especially at the beginning of the game where almost no one has done anything to progress the game yet.
  17. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    Alright, that actually makes more sense when I read it in context. Why doesn't it make her less likely? And yes, she /could/ be independent scum, but it would be reaching at best if I ignored it on that assumption.
  18. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    Some notes from my end: -Z3's post agreeing with my entrance and question 10 minutes later of how long the day is implies that he might not actually be reading that closely? I made it a point that we had to make a decision in 3 days. -bstrey's question to Creepa is probably more likely to come...
  19. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    It actually makes for better gameplay IMO, since it forces us to do things under the idea that someone is going to die no matter what. This may be a lost cause right now, but does anyone have something to share? First impressions, possible strategies, etc. Every game has to start somewhere.
  20. ElectroUnderwear

    Minr Mafia XIX: Retribution

    @CreepaShadowz Are we allowed to talk in the thread at night?
Top